Q.
Is Ishrat Jehan episode really a fake encounter as reported now?
Asked by Good Citizen,
09 Sep '09 10:25 am
Earn 10 points for answering
Answers (4)
1.
The final reports for the Ishrat Jahan encounter filed by the Ahmedabad metropolitan magistrate S.P. Tamang has finally come out and it proves to be be kind of setback for the Narendra Modi government. The controversial 2004 incident, for which the Modi government had already faced a lot of flak, has been judged to be an incident of another fake encounter case.
In the hand written report based on the encounter, which extends up to 243 pages, magistrate Tamang has highlighted the name of the then Gujarat police encounter specialist, D.G. Vanzara and others involved in the incident and accused them of the cold blooded murder of the 19 year old graduate student and three others.
Vanzara and quite a few of the others are already serving time in prison in regard to the Sohrabuddin encounter case, in which the State government has already confessed in front of the Supreme Court to be a case of fake encounter.
The slaying of the four suspect terrorists had been set for a reinvestigat ...more
Answered by dharamender nebhnani, 09 Sep '09 05:46 pm
In the hand written report based on the encounter, which extends up to 243 pages, magistrate Tamang has highlighted the name of the then Gujarat police encounter specialist, D.G. Vanzara and others involved in the incident and accused them of the cold blooded murder of the 19 year old graduate student and three others.
Vanzara and quite a few of the others are already serving time in prison in regard to the Sohrabuddin encounter case, in which the State government has already confessed in front of the Supreme Court to be a case of fake encounter.
The slaying of the four suspect terrorists had been set for a reinvestigat ...more
Report abuse
Useful
(1)
Not Useful
(0)
Your vote on this answer has already been received
2.
Not sure. But looks like it is now propped up for political mileage.
Answered by Roy, 09 Sep '09 05:03 pm
Report abuse
Useful
(0)
Not Useful
(0)
Your vote on this answer has already been received
3.
No it was not fake encounte this ishrat was with her friends went to Gujarat why her mother enquired about her daughter UPA govt. is in trouble at the time of elections they raised bogey of encounters related to Modi this anti Modi plot (oct there are elections in Maharashtra haryana ) cong want some benefits but they will not get
our judiciary is quick when there is any against BJP to give judgement
Answered by pramod gokhale, 09 Sep '09 11:48 am
our judiciary is quick when there is any against BJP to give judgement
Report abuse
Useful
(0)
Not Useful
(0)
Your vote on this answer has already been received
4.
Yes as per te hnews reports i twasa fake encountre
But BJP says earlier Central GOVT had conceded that it was real Anyways a few innocent liveswere lost for sure
Answered by SriniVenkat, 09 Sep '09 10:26 am
But BJP says earlier Central GOVT had conceded that it was real Anyways a few innocent liveswere lost for sure
Report abuse
Useful
(0)
Not Useful
(0)
Your vote on this answer has already been received