I think the Mitsubishi Outlander will surely give the Honda CRV some competition, something that the CRV has never faced ever since it entered the market, however I think even these are comparatively overpriced. The Captiva was also fresh when it entered the market, but again as you said overpriced.
Amongst the lot I think it will have to be the Outlander
Your vote on this answer has already been received
Honda CRV.Given it's quality,it is not over priced.But the newly launched Mitsubishi Outlander is not far behind.With almost the same features as that of the CRV(except the engine refinement),it is cheaper than the CRV by about Rs. 1 lakh.