Q.
Muslims brohter and sister i have one question for you:
If u join indian army and killed in war against Islamic Republic of Pakistan, then what's you status in Allah court.?
You know Holy Quran have great material about Muslims brotherhood, not mater which place u live.
Pass comments about this topic.
Asked by universaltruth,
24 Apr '08 02:31 pm
Earn 10 points for answering
Answers (8)
1.
I am forgiven in Allah's court, because I'm a combatant. And Islam rewards brave combatants. But if I die trying to destroy Mosques, or other civilian structures, there is hell for sure, but if it's an Indian ARmy MUslim soldier who got killed whilst fighting a Pakistani Army soldier in a battlefield, or any Muslim combatant- there is no hell.
A combatant only gets hell in Islam if he (or she) is involved in terror against civilians.
In the Second World War, the Grand Mufti of Bosnia declared open support to Hitler. (The Muslim divisions were the only ones that didn't have to wear the swastika in Hitler's army). The Grand Mufti also agreed that Bosnia should be a part of "Super Germany."
But you had other BOsnian Muslims who supported the Communist liberation movement against Hitler & the Bosnian SS, and these were led by the guerilla leader & freedom fighter- Josip Broz Tito.
So who goes to heaven here and who goes to hell?
ALso, in our na ...more
Answered by A Moin, 24 Apr '08 04:47 pm
A combatant only gets hell in Islam if he (or she) is involved in terror against civilians.
In the Second World War, the Grand Mufti of Bosnia declared open support to Hitler. (The Muslim divisions were the only ones that didn't have to wear the swastika in Hitler's army). The Grand Mufti also agreed that Bosnia should be a part of "Super Germany."
But you had other BOsnian Muslims who supported the Communist liberation movement against Hitler & the Bosnian SS, and these were led by the guerilla leader & freedom fighter- Josip Broz Tito.
So who goes to heaven here and who goes to hell?
ALso, in our na ...more
Report abuse
Useful
(0)
Not Useful
(0)
Your vote on this answer has already been received
2.
If muslims join indian army and killed in war against Islamic Republic of Pakistan, then your status in Allah court is that u r a honest & true muslim
Answered by Ajay Karmakar, 28 Apr '08 12:23 pm
Report abuse
Useful
(0)
Not Useful
(0)
Your vote on this answer has already been received
3.
Report abuse
Useful
(0)
Not Useful
(0)
Your vote on this answer has already been received
4.
you people are bluffing.in QURAN IT IS WRITTEN FIRST LOVE YOUR MOTHER LAND and next religion. even in pakistan 1400000 or more hindus are there.temples are there.one of the biggest hindu temple is in pakistan.their hidus love PAKISTAN
Answered by mohd basheer, 24 Apr '08 02:36 pm
Report abuse
Useful
(0)
Not Useful
(0)
Your vote on this answer has already been received
5.
I M not Muslim. But I know there is no such a court... we have only one chance no retake... so Jiyo aur jeene do
Answered by Jiya, 24 Apr '08 02:33 pm
Report abuse
Useful
(0)
Not Useful
(0)
Your vote on this answer has already been received
6.
quran says jisne eik musalman ko maara vo jannat mein nahi jaayega
aur hadith me aata hai jisne eik kaafir {non-muslim} ko mara vo jahannam mein nahi jaayega but thisa doesn't mean that you kill a kaafir without declaring a proper jihad there are many rules for jihad for more info. contact me at islamicjihad786@rediffmail.com
Answered by islamic jihad, 26 Apr '08 05:40 pm
aur hadith me aata hai jisne eik kaafir {non-muslim} ko mara vo jahannam mein nahi jaayega but thisa doesn't mean that you kill a kaafir without declaring a proper jihad there are many rules for jihad for more info. contact me at islamicjihad786@rediffmail.com
Report abuse
Useful
(0)
Not Useful
(0)
Your vote on this answer has already been received
7.
how dair do u have to ask all these type of noncence questions .waht do u think that terirism is Islamic Republic . first look at your question and then ask
Answered by sanjeev pal, 24 Apr '08 02:36 pm
Report abuse
Useful
(0)
Not Useful
(0)
Your vote on this answer has already been received
8.
I dono about that..... but there are several muslims who died for our country......
Answered by Pushkar, 24 Apr '08 02:33 pm
Report abuse
Useful
(0)
Not Useful
(0)
Your vote on this answer has already been received